Is It Cheaper to Buy or Make a Rug? Unraveling the Costs

Is It Cheaper to Buy or Make a Rug? Unraveling the Costs

Is It Cheaper to Buy or Make a Rug? Unraveling the Costs

When it comes to adding warmth and character to a space, rugs are a go-to for many homeowners and decorators. However, as with any home accessory, there's always a question that pops up: is it cheaper to buy a rug or to take on the challenge of making one? In this article, we'll weave through the details of rug costs, considering factors like materials, time, and the hidden expenses that could trip you up.

The Price Tag on Purchasing a Rug

The first option is to buy a rug, and the market offers a wide spectrum of choices, from affordable mass-produced designs to high-end, hand-knotted pieces. Here's what to consider:

Mass-Produced Rugs

These rugs are often machine-made using synthetic materials, which keeps costs down. You can find them at various retailers, both online on platforms like Shopify and in physical stores. Prices can range anywhere from $20 for a small, simple design, to several hundred dollars for a larger, more intricate rug. The advantage? It's a straightforward, one-time purchase with no extra effort needed.

Artisan and Designer Rugs

On the other end of the scale are the artisan rugs. Handmade by skilled craftspeople, these rugs are often made with high-quality, sustainable materials and can cost anywhere from a few hundred to several thousand dollars. The catch? While they're usually more durable and unique, the upfront cost is significantly higher.

Vintage and Antique Rugs

If you're eyeing a vintage or antique piece, the price climbs even higher due to their age, history, and potential rarity. Such rugs can be seen as investment pieces, often costing thousands of dollars.

The Cost of Crafting a Rug

For the DIY enthusiasts, making a rug can be an appealing project. However, the costs can be surprisingly high.


The cost of materials varies widely depending on the type of rug you want to make. Wool, for instance, is a popular choice for its durability and softness but can be costly. Other materials like cotton or synthetic yarns might offer a cheaper alternative but could compromise the rug's feel and longevity. You'll also need to factor in the tools you need, such as a loom, hooks, or other equipment, which can add to the initial outlay.

Time Investment

Your time is valuable, and rug-making is a time-consuming process, especially for larger or more complex designs. If you're new to rug-making, you'll also need to invest time in learning the craft, which could mean paying for classes or resources.

Hidden Costs

Mistakes can happen, especially with a skill-intensive project like rug-making. You might find yourself buying extra materials or tools along the way. Plus, if you're using expensive materials, a single error can be a costly one.

The Breakdown: Buying vs. Making

When Buying Might Be Cheaper:

  • You're looking for a standard-sized rug with a common design.
  • You value time over the customization of a DIY project.
  • You find a great deal on a mass-produced rug during a sale.

When Making Might Be Cheaper:

  • You already have the necessary tools and a stockpile of materials.
  • You're making a small rug or a simple design that doesn't require much yarn.
  • You're skilled at rug-making and can efficiently minimize waste and mistakes.

The Intangibles

Beyond the numbers, there's the satisfaction and personalization that comes with making something with your own hands. If you're a creative person or someone who enjoys crafts, the value of a handmade rug may far exceed any price tag.


Deciding whether to buy or make a rug isn't just about the bottom line; it's about considering the worth of your time, the joy of crafting, and the importance of unique design versus the convenience and immediate gratification of a purchase. If you're strictly budgeting, generally speaking, buying a mass-produced rug will be the cheaper route. But if you're looking for an heirloom piece that tells a story, making a rug could be a priceless experience.

Whether you decide to hit the "Add to Cart" button on a Shopify store or pick out yarns for your handcrafted masterpiece, consider all the angles to ensure that your new rug is a perfect fit for both your space and your wallet.

Please note, comments must be approved before they are published